Broadband-Hamnet™ Forum :: Problems & Answers
Welcome Guest   [Register]  [Login]
 Subject :Antennas.. 2013-12-12- 10:14:35 
N2PPN
Member
Joined: 2013-12-10- 20:09:30
Posts: 20
Location

Just wondering about antennas.... would an omni be better than a yagi? would TWO onmi's be better than two yagi's?? etc, etc...


I wonder if there is any advantage/disadvantage to disabling one of the antennas on the 54GS's...


All in all, what are YOUR experiences with antennas and what is/was your final decision and set up, both for indoor and or outdoor deployment...


(I ask this because I may be deploying nodes in several different environments... some indoors, like in a rooftop elevator machine room, mounting on a tower, or putting on a telephone pole...)


Rich

N2PPN

IP Logged
 Subject :Antennas.. 2013-12-12- 20:32:32 
wx5u
Member
Joined: 2013-01-02- 00:30:45
Posts: 188
Location: Austin, TX

A directional antenna has several advantages.  The gain gives you more range because your sent and received signal levels are higher.  You also pick up less interference from other devices because you don't "see" in as many directions.   You also cause interference with fewer other users.

Of course, you lose coverage area if you use a high gain antenna due to the narrower beam width.  It's a good way to make a link between one pair of stations, or perhaps connect to a few stations that happen to be in the same general direction.   One example would be a node on a high vantage point on the edge of town at some distance from a number of nodes concentrated in one direction such as the downtown area.

You can use the two antennas to make directional links in two different directions.   If you don't have a specific purpose for the second antenna, it's usually a good idea to just put a standard antenna on it.  It's often useful to be able to make an connection to the mesh node from somewhere nearby.  

However, there is no single answer.   You make many tradeoffs with antenna cost, coverage area, etc. 

IP Logged
I'm not part of the development team, so take what I say with a grain of salt. I'm also easily confused.

Check out the free Wireless Networking Book
Page # 


Powered by ccBoard


SPONSORED AD: